« Behind The Scenes Video: Heroes Makeup Magic | Main | Fancast Photos: Stars Attend Clinton-Obama Debate »

Justin Guarini Blogs About American Idol: Show 6

By Justin Guarini
Fancast American Idol Correspondent
Host of Idol Wrap and Idol Tonight, TV Guide Channel

idolmiami1.jpg

So I read a comment on yesterday’s post from Tanya who said, “I live in Omaha and this was a big deal for American Idol to come to our city.” Indeed. I’m glad that I acknowledged that. Can’t ever get too jaded; after all this is America Idol, and it is big no matter where it sets down. Better still, Tanya wrote, “I agree with your take on rock n’ roll. I used to be a huge fan, but today most of it sounds the same and I too have turned off the radio to the mainstream stations. You can only hear the same twenty songs so often before boredom sets…”

My point – and the most interesting topic for someone like me in the music business. Earlier in the evening I was on the phone with a very dear friend of mine who informed me that Emo is dead. Not Elmo, thank goodness. But Emo. Emo as in the style of dress/music/eyeliner-application…

In addition to Emo, my conversation with her made me realize a slew of other significant shifts that have occurred in the rock community – and all right under my nose. I suddenly I realized that my understanding of our rockin’ brethren is terribly ignorant or out of step. So much that I didn’t even know I was ignorant or out of step. Living in Hollywood has clearly dulled my rock senses. The bottom line, whether we’re talking about the status of Emo or punk rock, head-banging heavy metal, indie or alt, is that no matter the label stuck to it, music is boring right now.

Why is that? Is it the business? The artists? Or the times we live in? And where does Idol fit into the equation? Is it adding to the problem? Is it encouraging anything new and exciting? Or is it reflective of what’s going on in that scene that Tanya, my friend and I feel is boring?

Where does rock fit into Idol? Chris Daughtry by many peoples accounts should have won, or at least come second in his year. I’m not denying the awesome talent of Carrie Underwood, but where is Bo Bice? I think that mainstream rock is perfect for Idol, because mainstream rock is safe. Idol is safe. That’s why we can sit down with the whole family and watch it. This is good for family, and a great hallmark of the show…but ultimately feeds a blah mainstream industry.

Another thing that really “grinds my gears” is that I don’t understand how Jordan Sparks can have 30million people watch her win Idol, and then less than ½ of 1 percent of those people got the album the first week it was out! Does anyone else see the disconnect here? She’s a phenomenal vocalist, and made even more so by the fact that she’s so young. With the exception of Kelly and Carrie, where does Idol go astray after the lights go down?

I understand and applaud Idol for making a show that appeals to all peoples of all ages. It’s brilliant television, and I will always be proud to be a part of it. There was a time when I wasn’t, but it was before I put down my ego’s rebellion, and realized that the show ultimately gave me everything I’ve ever needed to make my way successfully through the entertainment industry. That being said, it’s after Idol where many a hope and dream are crushed, if not suppressed by the media and entertainment machine.

That’s where my head is at when I settle in to watch the latest Idol. I crack myself up by saying, “Bienvenido a Miami!

The funny thing is that most people watching the intro to the show won’t actually get the Miami Vice reference. It was a great show, but who under 20 actually remembers it? Ouch. If you never saw it, don’t remember it, or want to watch it again, don’t worry. You can watch full episodes of the classic series on Fancast by clicking here.

Anyway. My initial impressions: Whoa! What a minx! Paula came to town looking like a million bucks. Too bad Simon and Randy didn’t get the memo...anyway, bring on the sacrificial lambs!

Shannon McGough:
Oh man…another belcher. There was one a few years back, and it was not exactly the most attractive quality in a contestant…much less a lady. Ouch…ouch…ouch. How did she win Okeechobee Idol? Oh, then she goes and sings anyway over the judge’s comments, keep digging. This one kinda hurts my heart…but only a little. I’m all for interventions when their needed…but it still stings to watch a persons ego, or worse, their deeply ingrained understanding of the world-and where they fit into it-fall apart before their very eyes. Shannon has suffered from being told she’s good, all of her life. Sadly, it comes as no surprise then that she is shocked to find out she’s either been surrounded exclusively by nice people (really nice people) or the tone-deaf…all of her life. Ouch. The tinkling sound of the glass of her old realty hitting the floor seems to follow her down the escalator and out of the building.

Robbie:
Former boy-bander. I think I like this guy. Not that my opinion really matters, but lets just pretend that it does (I do all the time)…he’s good, but I see him (sorry) in a boy-band. The performance was circa 1995, and just plain good. . Even the silly string that his family sprays at him is dated, oh boy. The saving grace of this audition for me was Paula’s quip about Simon’s waffling. If looks could kill…Paula 1, Simon 0. He goes through, and I’m feeling Vanilla

Note to self: Bad ideas in an audition:
Pan flute
Cursing
Not being able to spell melody (much less find it)
Wearing a Marvin the Martian shirt and then singing notes that are ‘out of this world’
Playing air harmonica

idolmiami2.jpg

Ghaleb:
Is he really 27?? Get out of town! Oh well, at least he can play a guitar and even harmonica. By the way has anyone reading this ever tried to play harmonica? Holy @#%, it’s hard! I tried to pick it up on the casual tip…and fully understand the real reason why people put their hands over their mouth and the harmonica. No, it’s not to hold it, like we all think…it’s to hid the hideous things you have to do with your mouth to make that puppy sing. Ok so it’s not that dramatic, but still, I sucked at it and I give Ghaleb full marks for being able to do it with gusto. I’m not bowled over by the audition, and Paula hit it on the head as to why. He is talented though, and I think he’s gonna shake up Hollywood week when they let him accompany himself on guitar or harmonica.

Corliss and Brittany:
Corless can sing, but this is where song choice is very important. She can sing though…and well. Brittany, same story, but the song was more on the mark. Both of them have got to go through. They’re fun and they’re certainly not shy. Going to Hollywood! Not surprising.

My Big Audition:
When I last left off, I was thanking my lucky stars that Ken Warwick (one of Idol’s executive producers) and another guy whose name I’ll never know, didn’t throw me to the wolves. After my puzzling encounter, I made my way back to the holding room for a nice hot dish of hurry-up-and-wait.

Zzzzz…my wait was long and indeterminable. The waiting room we were assigned to was very stylish and modern…lots of brushed concrete, funky couches, and some artsy modern piece that hung from the ceiling. They didn’t have a clock in the room and I usually don’t wear a watch. I just wanted to get it over and done with. The wait was almost as traumatic as the actual process of auditioning.

Finally my name was called to go see the dreaded judges. In reality, I didn’t feel an ounce of dread; the wait had numbed any feeling out of me. Also, I didn’t know much about the process or the judges. I had been told that Paula would be there, but I still didn’t believe it. It’s all a bit fuzzy now (five frickin’ years later) but what stands out in sharp relief for me is the moment I didn’t lay eyes on Paula.

That’s right…didn’t.

Because of my father’s work, I grew up around well-known show business and political figures. So celebrities didn’t impress me. As far as I’m concerned, we’re all the same. The only things that separate us are the labels we wear and those that are placed upon us. Which is why it was a little ridiculous that I couldn’t bring myself to look at Paula when she strode purposely out of the audition room.

Or course there was a reason. A) Because she was forever my girl; or B) She had to go to the bathroom and I was already in line for the bathroom, one ahead of her.

In any event, she snuck up on me.

I was minding my own business, about to take my “pre-performance whiz” (I shouldn’t have told you that, but it’s true, it’s a ritual, and that’s what I call it) when lo and behold, as my bladder is ready to loose any tension left in my body…Paula showed up.

I think I glanced at her, realized it was her, and then stared at the floor. It happened very quickly, in about a nanosecond. I couldn’t believe Paula Abdul was behind me. I couldn’t believe how badly I had to go. (Knowing Paula, she probably had to go pretty badly too.) And though my chivalrous instinct was to let her go ahead of me, I didn’t know if I’d be able to hold out, if you know what I mean. And I had to audition! Well, I asked if she wanted to go ahead of me. She declined…sweetly.

What was I supposed to do? Force her in? No, that wouldn’t have been wise. The beefy gentleman at her side, aka her bodyguard, would not have taken kindly to that.

‘Uh, thanks’ I said and went in to the bathroom.

Then panic set in.

As soon as the door closed behind me, I realized that I was suddenly Paula’s opening act. I was setting the tone for her bathroom experience. Oh God, so much pressure, so many thoughts rushing at me:

-What if I whiz on the seat, or just miss altogether?
-Oh, God…please, please don’t pass gas in here the smell will never dissipate in time.
-What’s this puddle at the base of the toilet, I didn’t do that. Will she think I did?
-This place is a mess, should I use that mop in the corner…
-Oh God, now I can’t pee cause I’m too nervous…etc.

My whole world revolved around not completely ruining my shot at the big time over a poor bathroom performance. I wasn’t even in the room yet and I was sweating. As I exited the bathroom (hopefully left none the worse for wear) I prayed that my first impression wouldn’t be a toilet seat left in the up position. Paula didn’t say anything, I think I smiled with eyes averted, and got out of Dodge.

Unfortunately the audition shows are running for a month…so too must my audition tale.

Back to tonight’s show…

Suzanne Toon:
The sappy guitar heralds the contestant story. Single mother, beautiful daughter, and a great voice…great story. I have hope for her and once she beats the nerves…she’ll be even better.

(sigh) I’m getting bored of writing about each contestant…you can go to other sites to catch that stuff.

idolmiami3.jpg

Here are the highlights-

Siesha Mercado:
Powerhouse, story, beautiful, no surprise

Where are the guys?

Ouch.

Ouch.

Carroy Bethea:
His hair looks like what mine would look like if I tried to do complex calculus without the aid of a calculator.

Grant Rhea:
Sounds exactly like what Whitney would sound like singing that song nowadays.

Julie Dubela:
Set up right from the beginning. Confident, but the judge’s reactions show that she’s in for trouble. It turns salty…quick. Oh, then she tries to sing over the judge’s disapproval. Ahhhh. Oops. Then she complains her way out of the building…bitterly.

Brandon Black:
Gets the “Plow Through It” award. Wow. I mean wow. It was the single greatest audition to watch in Idol history. He’s the total package and will definitely make it back to the finale.

Oh my Gosh! How many audition shows are there? Damn.

I'm going to be busy. Well, here’s to massive advertising revenues for Fox.

Until next time…

JG


homepage photo credit: Matt Beard

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://216.183.124.111/cgi-bin/cim-mt/mt-tb.cgi/1542

Comments (17)

Danica:

"Ghaleb:
Is he really 27?? Get out of town! "

Ha! That's exactly what I said when I saw him! I feel so refreshed when I read your blog b/c it gives me confidence that there is hope for the music industry. You recognize the problems and I can't wait to see what goodies you will provide us with on your album (that is supposed to be coming SOON (as you said in Sewell and Flint!) remember??? lol)! Can't wait for next week!

Danica

Jo:

Justin, your 'bathroom drama' gives a totally new meaning/context to the concept of 'performance anxiety'....LOL!! And truth be told I am having such fun reading about your personal (and wow do you give personal!) Idol experieces I wouldn't mind a bit if you skipped the whole 'audition' commentary! But either way I am now a captivated reader, never disappointed....except when I realize I cannot 'turn the page' and keep on reading! Thanks for the fun Justin!!

Shelley:

OMG! You had me rolling on he floor with the bathroom episode!
Your blogs make me feel like I'm talking and laughing with you
in person. You were blessed with many talents, Justin. Looking
forward to what comes next.


Mindy:

Justin,

It's so interesting to hear your story about your audition process and all the things that go on behind the scenes.....the bathroom story was hysterical! To answer your question, about Idol and it's contribution to mainstream music. In my opinion it is helping to perpetuate the "blah" music we hear on the radio everyday and it really hasn't added anything new or different to the mix, however, I think the Idol producers and Simon want someone that fits into the current "pop box" because that's what people are listening to. I think the fact that Jordin Sparks didn't sell that many albums is a sign that the public may be growing weary of what they are being force fed. The thing that really "grinds my gears" as you said is that somewhere along the line America has decided the louder the music the better it is.

Looking forward to future blogs.

Nal:

Seriously great stuff. I'd write more, but I'm still laughing too hard from reading your pre-audition tale. LOL.

Justin,

I really enjoy writing your blog. It's my first professional blog, and so far so good. Thanks for letting me take the time to sit down and just get it all out. I have so many things swirling around in my head that sometimes it takes me 3 hours or more to focus enough to get it done...thanks for being patient with me. Keep up the work, and make sure you thank that Todd Gold guy for being a damn fine editor.

Cheers,

Justin

Christy:

Justin, your blogs never fail to make me smile and laugh. Thanks for sharing your experiences and thoughts with us. The bathroom story was hilarious. I agree with Jo. If you wrote about your time on Idol only, that would be A-OK with me. ;)

Christy

jpet:

To quote Monk: LOL OUT LOUD.

Joyce:

Justin,
I just love reading your blog. I always want more. You have a such a wonderful way with words. You are a wonderful entertainer on so many levels. Looking forward to the next installement. LOL about the bathroom incident. Thanks for sharing so much of yourself with us.

ExMenudoFan:

ROFLMAO!!!! I love your bathroom story!

Have you ever thought about becoming a fiction writer? I know it's a lot to juggle considering all your other jobs but I have to tell you, I'm enjoying your blogs more than the last book I read.

ExMenudoFan:

ROFLMAO!!!! I love your bathroom story!

Have you ever thought about becoming a fiction writer? I know it's a lot to juggle considering all your other jobs but I have to tell you, I'm enjoying your blogs more than the last book I read.

Nicole:

Justin,
This is nothing related to your blog . . . but just wondering when your coming back to Mass?

All I can say is....priceless.
Simply priceless. In the best possible way. :D

Lee:

ROFL

Janna:

Justin,

I just found this blog and thought it was insightful and funny. I'm going to go back and read 1 thru 5. American Idol is getting a little boring and your blog brings a whole new perspective to the show. I will be looking forward to your blogs each week.

Carroy:

This is Carroy, you know, the one that didnt use a calculator when doing the complex calculus. lol. I'm going to prove that I can really sing one day. I must tell you though, I didnt go on the show in search for a major record deal. I went for the exposure. I'm currently a drama teacher and i would love nothing more than to be an actor on the big screen. So Tyler Perry if your reading, give me a call. lol. thanks

ExMenudoFan:

Where's the next blog? I'm dying here!

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)