
By Bob Hellman
Comedy Correspondent
After reading the earlier post about the reading of Neil Simon's play "The Odd Couple," I was reminded of its sitcom adaptation and then inspired to come up with a list of the 10 greatest sitcoms ever. Is it the definitive list? You decide. It was mighty hard to pick just 10, I'll tell you that.
How did I do it? Easy. I’ve been watching television since the day after I was born. That makes me an expert. When I was in grade school I used to tape record (cassettes, remember those?) sitcoms and listen to them while my parents thought I was sleeping. Then, in junior high, I would rush home to watch Match Game. By high school I planned my schedule so I’d be home just in time to catch the last 45 minutes of Love Boat.
Since it was to be only 10 sitcoms that I featured, many of my faves were left off the list. Taxi, Sanford & Son and of course, The Addams Family. So, those above credentials, combined with the fact that I own many television sets makes me duly qualified to have composed the list of the 10 best sitcoms ever -- according to me! Agree? Disagree? Let me know.
10) The Larry Sanders Show. Behind the scenes of a late night talk show. Timing is everything, especially here, Sanders hit the air at a perfect time. During the Johnny Carson retirement era. It was the first show within a show. Jeffrey Tambor’s “Hank” is one of the funniest characters ever on television. I still find myself saying “Hey Now” all the time. Rip Torn as the Executive Producer who was always putting out a fire on the show could make you laugh by just looking into the camera. Garry Shandling will never top this role, he truly was a neurotic self centered talk show host. It was also the first show to have celebrities playing themselves every week and we could actually believe that The Larry Sander’s Show was a real talk show.
9) The Munsters. Yes, The Munsters. How can you not laugh at a show with a family like that? They were regular people with regular problems trapped in the bodies of a monster, a vampire, a warlock, and a witch. The fact that they were placed in everyday society can’t be topped. I wish I was in that network pitch meeting. “It’s a show about an average family. They just happen to be a Frankenstein clone, a vampire, a warlock, and a witch.”
8) Cheers. While when it aired I can honestly say I wasn’t a big fan. Then I started watching the show in repeats. It was there that the fantastic writing shined for me. Funny dumb jokes, brilliant storylines, these characters seemed like people we all knew. Also, the fact that it all took place in a single setting, the bar, is a true testament to the writing and acting skills.
7) M*A*S*H. Yes, a sitcom about surgeons during a war is funny. Even if it did last 17 years longer than the Korean War it was to take place during. While it may have gotten preachy at times, it was still good. Even when this show went through cast changes it maintained hilarity. But still, the original cast was the best. And how can you not love surgeons that make their own booze?
6) I Love Lucy. The granddaddy of every sitcom. A simple formula that has been used in almost every sitcom since that show. Especially Seinfeld. Every episode had the same theme, get into trouble, get into more trouble, get out of trouble. This show would also be ranked higher by me if not for the horrible spin-offs it had.
5) The Honeymooners. Great writing. That can be attested to the fact that practically every episode took place on the same set, Ralph and Alice’s apartment. Not to mention that in practically every episode they wore the same clothes. And may I say that Ed Norton as the “Man From Mars” will be funny forever.
4) Curb Your Enthusiasm. I know what you’re thinking, finally a recent show has made the list! Well that’s because it’s the only recent show that’s funny. Larry David is a genius. His character and the fact that plenty of the show isn’t scripted is the mark of sheer talent all the way around. Larry knows how, and I hate using clichés, to push the envelope. The cast actually brings their own personalities to their characters. That’s comedy at its finest. The writing and storylines are brilliant in every episode.
3) All In The Family. This is a toss up. I would have put this at number two but it stayed on the air way past its prime. And it gets knocked down a number because of the dreadful spin-off “Archie Bunker’s Place.” Here’s a little known fact about Carroll O’Conner, had he gotten the part of the Skipper on “Gilligan’s Island” we would never have been blessed with Archie Bunker.
2) Seinfeld. While it was hailed as a show about nothing, it was really about something: People’s neuroses. Every episode is still funny in reruns. Great characters, brilliant writing, and stories that all intertwined with each other and wrapped up at the end of every episode.
1) The Odd Couple. Hands down the best show ever on television. Nothing will ever top it. There wasn’t one episode that didn’t make me laugh. It was just so simple. Messy Oscar and nitpicky Felix. Even the voice over intro was hilarious. “..Can two divorced men share an apartment without driving each other crazy?” That set the whole tone.